Why does everyone want to be Chic, Niche, and a Cool Girl?
If you're anywhere on TikTok, Instagram, or Substack, you've probably come across a post titled "Things I Find Incredibly Chic," "Cool Girl Shoes", or "Niche Never Seen Brands." This style of content is saturating the internet to the point where nothing is chic, niche, or cool anymore. Which, on the contrary, makes anything chic: jeans with heel bite, a basic white tee, toast. But the real question is why everyone is so obsessed with these buzzwords in the first place.
The answer, I believe, has less to do with taste than with fear, specifically the fear of looking like you're trying. The chicness epidemic began to rise at the tail end of the performativity plague, a period in which everything was performative, even genuine interest. Being called performative was, and still is, one of the worst insults you can throw at someone. It's an accusation that goes past your clothes and into your motives: it questions the authenticity of your interest, your style, and the fundamentals of identity.

The thing about niche, chic, and “the cool girl” is that none of them actually have to do with the clothing itself. They describe a relationship between a person and their clothes, suggesting the relationship is natural and uncoached. Each word is a different way of conveying the same idea: nobody told me to do this. Chicness connotes effortlessness; it says the person wearing the outfit didn’t put too much thought into it, but you still think it's cool. Niche denies influence and mainstream appeal. The Cool Girl projects uniqueness, making her seem different from everyone else. Within these definitions, there’s a pattern: chic denies effort, niche denies influence, cool denies sameness. These three denials are aimed at thwarting the accusation that you are trying, that you were told, that you want something—in other words, that you are performing.

One fear fuels the outfits. Chic stops being chic when everyone can identify it; niche stops being niche when it has a name; and the Cool Girl stops being cool the second she's a type you can shop for. The vocabulary meant to mark distinction is becoming the surest sign that distinction is gone.
This anxiety isn't new, but the conditions that feed it are. Every outfit is now potentially content, which means every choice is potentially a performance, and the platforms reward popularity. The internet has encouraged us to learn what will get us likes and gain popularity, which is the exact opposite of not trying. As a result, the fashion and trend cycle goes as fast as it comes. Dupes arrive within weeks of a runway show, and luxury logos are everywhere; price no longer divides, so the last thing left to lose status over is trying. You can see the industry answering this in real time: the rise of unbranded leather goods, the pivot to quiet luxury, the sudden emphasis on fabric composition over logos, the styling advice that tells you to remove one accessory before you leave the house—not to be too flashy or not flashy enough. All of it is fashion selling effortlessness back to people terrified of being caught making an effort. The result is a contradiction. The anti-performative look is itself performed, at scale, on the very platforms that make performance unavoidable.
The way out of performance isn’t to perform indifference more convincingly, because that's just another performance. It is to actually stop caring about what outside voices think of you and your outfits. If you like something that the it-girl of the week is wearing, buy it. If you like something that's out of trend, wear it. True nicheness comes from genuine interest, and the “cool girl” will never be cool to everyone. Life is too short to calculate every jacket and accessory you put on, so wear whatever the hell you want!




Comments